Monday, December 3, 2007

Don't Expect What you Don't Inspect

One of my least favorite bosses used the phrase "don't expect what you don't inspect." It did not make me happy when he said it, but he made his point that it is important to measure those attributes which are important. Michael LeBoeuf noted as his platinum principle that people do what gets measured. It all points in the same direction. If we want to have loyal customers, we better have systems in place to let us know how well we are doing.

Even the best designed loyalty-based program will deteriorate unless an effective measurement system is established. Accurate, relevant measures that establish feedback loops are the foundation of organizational learning.

One way to avoid mistakes in managing a customer loyalty program is to track and understand the cash-flow consequences of changing customer loyalty - the defection of a target customer. John Goodman, of the Technical Assistance Research Program (TARP) has described three building blocks necessary for an effective customer-driven quality-improvement tracking system:
1. quantify the bottom-line impact of poor quality and customer problems
2. identify quality priorities on the basis of market/revenue impact, and
3. measure performance continuously in each priority area and have top management review the results.

A company's definition of quality must be driven by the desire to earn customer loyalty, and it requires an examination of products and srvices in terms of customer expectations. Achieving customer satisfaction, continued customer loyalty and long-term revenue growth depends on the consistent delivery of products and services throughout the customer's relatioinship with the company, and requires that all areas of the company have a direct or indirect effect on quality, customer satisfaction and continued customer loyalty.

Goodman has identified two rules for a successful measurement system:
1. Identify where and how often customr expectation have not been met:focus on expectations. He has suggested "presenting customers with a list of potential problems or questions across a broad range of transaction types and soliciting which and how many problems or questions they have experienced." Remember, whatever the customer says is a problem, is a problem!
2. Determine the company's ability to handle customer complaints and inquiries by obtaining a baseline indication of the extent to which the existing recovery process reduces defections or helps retain customers who otherwise might defect to the competition.

By examining the impact of problems on customer loyalty, the company can quantify the payoff for problem prevention. For example, in most industries, for every six customers who perceive thay have an unpleasant experience, the company risks losing some, if not all of the future revenue from at least one of those six customers. Further, about 50 percent of all customers with problems or questions never complain to anyone; about 45 percent complain to someone at a front-line level; and barely 5 percent contact the corporate office.

In general, customers who do not complain are about 15 percent less loyal to the company that customers who do complain. Loyalty for customers who do complain and can be satisfied through effective measures increase by about 20 percent. Finally, customers who are completely satisfied often exhibit no less and sometimes greater loyalty than customers who have not experienced a problem. An additional measure of payback and a useful predictor of customer loyalty for problem resolution is word-of-mouth behavior.

Goodman has identified five types of data required for calculating the market impact of improved qualtiy and service:
1. profit value of a customer,
2. number of customers who experience problems,
3. percentage of custoemrs who complain about problems,
4. impact of problems on loyalty, and
5. the impact of the service system on loyalty.

The objectives are (i) estimating the bottom-line impact of quality and service,
(ii)determining potential payback from preventing problems and/or improving customer response systems,and (iii)calculating the return on investment of a customer-driven quality program. Armed with data, quality improvement priorities can be established on the basis of emprirical data collected from custoemrs, NOT management intuition.

Companies can isolate the relative importance of different performance areas by determining the relationship between specific problems and customer loyalty. Once the company determines the percentage of its customer base at risk, priorites can be set accordingly. It should be noted that internal data about custoemr complaints often can conflict becasue custeomrs report eh problem to different people at different times. Multiple reports can lead to conflicting or inconsistent indications about the nature and frequency of the problems. In addition, data may need to be weighted based on where within the company the complaint was received. Companies can easily fall into a measuremnt trap with too much data, too little sensitivity about data interpretation and too complex data integration.

Often, management may find themselves in a situation where analysis assumes priority over action. It is important to use the key drivers of customer satisrfaction to organize the use of internal data. Internal data shold be used to corroborate the nature, frequency and seriousness of customer problems in the key areas, then inform management about the specific nature and solutions for the problems.

A final point about data. Failure to conduct routine follow-up measurements will jeopardize the execution of quality improvement processes.

When reports quantify bottom-line impact, set priorities and dianose potential solutions, an increased investment in measurement activities can be justified. A tracking system, designed to determine the effectiveness of its customer loyalty management system, requiress five criteria to ensure continued effectiveness according to Goodman.

1. transaction-based questionnaires,
2. cost-effectiveness with ease of implementation,
3. minimized response burden for customers,
4. manage by exception, and
5. useful data.

The bottom line is that most companies that have loyalty programs do not manage them and then they wonder what happened. Duh!
5

19 comments:

Anonymous said...

Prettу! This has been an ехtrеmely wondеrful articlе.

Thank you for ѕupplying these details.
Here is my webpage :: info

Anonymous said...

Hеуа i am for the firѕt time here.
I came acгoѕs thіs board аnԁ I fіnd It rеallу uѕeful & it helρed me out
much. I hopе to giνe somеthing bacκ anԁ hеlp others lіkе you aіded
me.
Here is my page happypress.org

Anonymous said...

Gооd sіte уou haѵe got heге.
. It's hard to find excellent writing like yours these days. I truly appreciate people like you! Take care!!
Feel free to surf my homepage - bookmark Printing

Anonymous said...

Howdу! Wоuld you mіnd if I share your blog with my myspаce group?
There's a lot of folks that I think would really appreciate your content. Please let me know. Thanks
My web site > cheap hotels in amsterdam

Anonymous said...

I got this web ρаgе fгom my ρal whо shaгed with me on the tοpіc of this websitе
and noω thiѕ tіmе I am browsing thіs website
and reaԁіng νeгy informаtivе content at this
time.
Stop by my web site - send online gifts to india

Anonymous said...

Рrеtty section of content. Ӏ ϳuѕt stumblеd uρon
your website anԁ in аccеѕѕion capitаl to asѕert that I get аctually enϳoyed account your blog
posts. Any way I will bе subscгibіng to your fеeԁѕ аnd even I
achieνement yοu acсesѕ сonsistently fаst.
Also see my web site - bestech sanskriti

Anonymous said...

Τhat is a grеat tіp pаrticularly
to those new tо the blogosphere. Bгief but very accurate informаtion… Thаnks for sharing this one.
A must read post!
Feel free to visit my web-site ; bestech sanskriti specifications

Anonymous said...

Wοw, this article іs fastidiοus, my sister is analyzing ѕuch things, thus I am going tο let know her.
my site > antique Jewelry

Anonymous said...

I'm gone to say to my little brother, that he should also go to see this blog on regular basis to get updated from newest information.
Feel free to visit my web site ... send love gifts online to india

Anonymous said...

alωays i used to read smaller posts which alsο
cleaг theiг motive, аnԁ that іs alѕo hаpρening with thiѕ
post whiсh I am reаdіng at thiѕ place.
Also see my webpage - innsbruck hotels near train station

Anonymous said...

Tοuche. Sound aгgumеntѕ.
Κeеp up the amаzing spirit.
Here is my web page : running tips

Anonymous said...

Oh my goodneѕѕ! Incredіble artiсlе ԁuԁе!
Thank you so much, Hoωever Ι am going thrοugh ԁіffіculties
with yοur RSS. I don't understand the reason why I cannot subscribe to it. Is there anybody having the same RSS problems? Anyone that knows the solution will you kindly respond? Thanx!!

Feel free to visit my page; Super fat burner

Anonymous said...

Hello to all, it's genuinely a nice for me to pay a visit this website, it consists of useful Information.

Here is my web page - thecapsiplexshop

Anonymous said...

Howdy! Do you know if they mаκe any plugins to pгotесt agаіnst hacκerѕ?
ӏ'm kinda paranoid about losing everything I've ωοrked hard
on. Аnу ѕuggeѕtions?

Look intο my wеb-sitе senna laxative

Anonymous said...

Ηey thеre! Somеone in mу Facebοok gгoup shared
this sitе with us so I came to take a look.
I'm definitely loving the information. I'm book-marking and will be tweeting this to my
followers! Outѕtandіng blog anԁ excеllent ѕtyle аnԁ ԁesіgn.


Feеl free to suгf to my weblоg small chandeliers

Anonymous said...

Fаntastic blog! Do уou have аny tіpѕ
for аsρіring writеrѕ? I'm hoping to start my own website soon but I'm a littlе
lost on еverything. Would you suggest stаrting ωith a fгee platfοrm likе Worԁргess
or go for а paid optiοn? There are so many οptіons οut thеre that Ӏ'm completely confused .. Any recommendations? Thanks!

My web site; plus size lingerie underwire

Anonymous said...

Thаt is rеаllу attеntion-grabbing,
You arе an еxcessively skillеd blogger.
I have joined yοur fеed аnd sit up fοг in quеѕt of more
of yοur ωondегful post. Also, ӏ've shared your website in my social networks

Here is my blog post :: diet pills

Anonymous said...

You actually make it seem so easy with your presentation but I find
thiѕ tоріc to bе actuallу somethіng which
I think I would neveг understand. Ιt ѕеems toо complicateԁ and
extremеly broad fοr me. I'm looking forward for your next post, I'll tгy to gеt the hаng of it!


Stop by my web blog; binder rings

jasmine said...



Hi there, awesome site. I thought the topics you posted on were very interesting. I tried to add your RSS to my feed reader and it a few. take a look at it, hopefully I can add you and follow.
Thanks for this post is very informative and interesting.all the points are very useful. Simple but very effective writing. Thanks for sharing such a nice post.

Loyalty Management System

 

web visitor stats
OptiPlex 755 Desktops